The MLB Free Agency Menu, Part 1: Headliners

Step right up and make your choice.

Share
The MLB Free Agency Menu, Part 1: Headliners

It’s decision time. With the lockout’s freeze on baseball business coming up at the start of December, MLB’s offseason will mostly happen with a rare time crunch element added in.

Like reaching the front of the line at a bustling counter-service restaurant, teams need to know what they want and speak for it quickly, lest indecision cost them the pastry, burrito or pitcher of their dreams. As your friendly neighborhood baseball newsletter writer, I guess my job is to elucidate the menu.

We’re going to take a spin through the types of players a team might want, and briefly break down the options they have to satisfy their craving. This won’t be a traditional ranking and projection of free agents — there are good ones at Baseball Prospectus and FanGraphs as usual — but it will reflect the murky bounds of how the experts view the players in each section.

I’m breaking this into two parts that roughly divide as Headliners Edition and Sickos Edition. We’re starting with the headliners. The sickos edition — starting with relief aces — is coming this week.

OK with that, let’s hurry up and go before more players sign.

Do you want a Tarik Skubal?

The menu: It’s just Tarik Skubal, obviously

Skubal doesn’t require much explanation: Reliably elite aces are rare. There’s just the one on offer this winter, so whoever wants him is going to have to open the wallet and flash the cash. It figures to take $40 million a year or a longer-than-you-want-term deal that effectively stretches that number out into more payments.

But I want to talk about that “reliably elite” designation I used. It’s why Skubal will cost so much. Over the past four seasons, there are only five pitchers who have thrown 500 innings with a sub-3.00 ERA. So, average 125 innings a year, and be roughly 25% better than the average MLB pitcher, by park-adjusted ERA-. That’s the ask, and only five guys have done it. Skubal is one, and he has cleared the bar by a good margin. He’s at a 2.47 ERA across 626 1/3 innings.

Will he continue apace? In a realm of “who knows?” he’s as close as you can come to saying yes. Thus, the price tag is steakhouse-coded: MKT.

Do you want to bet on a No. 2 starter?

The menu: Sonny Gray, Trevor Rogers, Freddy Peralta, Michael King

Everyone who doesn’t get Skubal will turn their attention to the next best thing. More available, more subjective, more questionable pitchers who appear good enough to start playoff games. This is where discussion and deliberation really heats up.

I think one thing is pretty clear.